Method of producing iron-chromium-aluminum alloys with improved high temperature properties

ABSTRACT

A powder metallurgy product comprising iron and chromium, and/or aluminum and characterized by elongated grains that are stable at elevated temperatures. A method of producing such a product, including mechanically alloying a suitable powder charge, consolidating the mechanically alloyed powder, working the consolidated product so as to achieve therein a reduction of at least about 10 percent; and, then, heating the worked product to produce coarse elongated grains therein. The product produced according to the present invention exhibits good oxidation resistance and good room temperature and elevated temperature strength and ductility.

United States Patent Cairns et al.

Sept. 24, 1974 METHOD OF PRODUCING IRON-CHROMIUM-ALUMINUM ALLOYS WITH IMPROVED HIGH TEMPERATURE PROPERTIES Inventors: Robert Lacock Cairns; John [63] Continuation-in-part of Ser. No. 218,404, Jan. 17,

1972, abandoned.

[52] US. Cl. 148/l1.5 F [51] Int. Cl. B22f 3/18, C21d 7/19 [58] Field of Search 148/11.5 F; 29/1825 [56] References Cited UNITED STATES PATENTS 2,409,797 10/1946 Rehnqvist 75/124 2,580,171 12/1951 Hagglund et al.. 75/126 3,159,908 12/1964 Anders 29/1825 3,346,427 10/1967 Baldwin et al.. 148/1 1.5 F 3,366,515 1/1968 Fraser et al. 148/11.5 F 3,368,883 2/1968 Barnett et al.. 29/1825 3,591,365 7/1971 Ohmachi 75/124 Assignee:

Filed:

Stanwood Benjamin, both of Suffern, NY.

The International Nickel Company,

Inc., New York, NY.

Jan. 22, 1973 Appl. N0.: 325,313

Related US. Application Data OTHER PUBLICATIONS Wukusick et al.; An Iron-Chromium-Aluminum Alloy Containing Yttrium; Materials Research & Standards; 12/1964, pp. 637646.

Oda et al.; Dispersi0n-Strengthened Ferritic Heat-Resisting Steel; Modern Developments in Powder Metallurgy; H. H. Hausner, Ed.; Plenum Press, N.Y.; 1971, Vol. 5; pp. 159168.

Primary ExaminerW. W. Stallard [5 7 ABSTRACT A powder metallurgy product comprising iron and chromium, and/or aluminum and characterized by elongated grains that are stable at elevated temperatures.

A method of producing such a product, including mechanically alloying a suitable powder charge,

consolidating the mechanically alloyed powder, working the consolidated product so as to achieve therein a reduction of at least about 10 percent; and, then, heating the worked product to produce coarse elongated grains therein.

The product produced according to the present invention exhibits good oxidation resistance and good room temperature and elevated temperature strength and ductility.

5 Claims, 2 Drawing Figures PAIENIEU SEPZMQM FIG.E

FIG. 2

METHOD OF PRODUCING IRON-CHROMIUM-ALUMINUM ALLOYS WITH IMPROVED HIGH TEMPERATURE PROPERTIES This application is a continuation-in-part of US. Application Ser. No. 218,404, filed Jan. 17, 1972, and now abandoned.

conventionally-produced iron-base alloys containing chromium and aluminum exhibit oxidation resistance of a high order, even at elevated temperatures, but are of limited practical utility because they exhibit relatively low high-temperature strength, and are generally subject to extreme grain coarsening and grain boundary embrittlement when exposed for extended times to elevated temperatures. Such alloys exhibit negligible room temperature ductility after exposure to high temperature for extended periods of time. As a result of these drawbacks, the use of such alloys has largely been restricted to high-temperature applications at which little strength is required, e.g., electrical resistance heating elements, and to lower temperature applications where corrosion conditions preclude the use of other materials. It is, therefore, desirable to overcome the above-mentioned drawbacks so that such alloys can be used in various other high temperature applications requiring strength and corrosion resistance, such as turbines vanes, burner cans and blades.

It appeared that the problem of drastic loss of ductility in such iron-base alloys upon long-time exposure of the materials to elevated temperature could be solved if the massive grain growth found to occur therein during such elevated temperature exposure could be prevented.

The mechanical alloying process described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,591,362 to Benjamin, provides a method of uniformly distributing dispersoid particles at close spacings in such alloys.

Briefly, in the mechanical alloying process, as described in the above patent, the constituent metal particles of the starting powder charge are integrated together into dense composite particles without melting any of the constituents, this being done by dry milling the powder, usually in the presence of grinding media, e.g., balls, so as to apply to the powder charge, mechanical energy in the form of a plurality of repeatedlyapplied high energy, compressive forces. Such high energy forces result in the fracture, or comminution, of the original powder constituents and the welding together of the fragments so produced, as well as the repeated fracture and re-welding of the welded fragments, so that there is brought about a substantially complete codissemination of the fragments of the various constituents of the starting powder. The mechanically alloyed composite powder particles produced in this manner are characterized metallographically by cohesive internal structures in which the constituents are intimately united to provide an interdispersion of comminuted fragments of the starting constituents. Very short distances across the areas corresponding to the fragments of initial materials in the composite particles can be created, e.g., on the order of 3 microns or 1 micron or less, and fine dispersoid particles present in the powder charge can be uniformly distributed throughout the composite particles at short interparticle spacings, e.g., one micron or less.

The mechanical alloying process may be conducted in a variety of equipment, including a stirred ball mill,

shaker mill, vibratory ball mill. planetary ball mill, and even certain ball mills provided attention is had to the ball-to-powder ratio of the charge and size of the mill, as taught by the above Benjamin patent.

It has been found particularly advantageous in obtaining optimum results to employ agitation milling under high energy conditions in which a substantial portion of the mass of the attritive elements, e.g., balls, is maintained kinetically in a highly activated state of relative motion. The milling is sufficiently energetic to reduce substantially the thickness of the initial metal constituents by impact compression resulting from collisions with the milling medium, e.g., grinding balls. It has been found advantageous that at least about 40 percent, e.g., 50 or percent or even percent or more, of the attritive elements be maintained in a highly activated state.

By maintaining the attritive elements in a highly activated state of mutual collision in a substantially dry environment and throughout substantially the whole mass, optimum conditions are provided for comminuting and cold welding the constituents, accompanied by particle growth, to produce within each composite particle, a mechanically alloyed structure of the constituents. The resulting composite metal powder will be heavily cold worked and will reach a high hardness level, which becomes substantially constant (saturation hardness) after a minimum milling time due to impact compression of the particles arising from repeated collision of the attractive elements upon the metal particles, such hardness level providing stored energy to the composite powder particles.

In the interest of providing composite particles of substantially uniform composition and structure, milling is usually conducted beyond the point at which saturation hardness is reached.

We have now discovered a powder metallurgy process for producing iron-base alloys containing chromium and/or aluminum, which is based upon the use of mechanically alloyed powders and which provides alloys having markedly improved properties over a range of temperatures up to at least about 2000F. We have also discovered processing cycles which provide such alloys with a stable, elongated grain structure having improved strength at elevated temperatures and having good ductility over a wide range of temperatures, permitting the provision of mill products, including sheet, plate, wire, rod, tubing, etc., of greatly enhanced utility as compared to such articles produced by conventional means. Such grains provide to the consolidated products significant improvement in the tensile and stressrupture strengths and ductility at elevated temperatures.

It is therefore an object of this invention to provide an iron base material having improved high temperature strength.

It is a further object to provide such an iron base material that exhibits good room temperature ductility even after extended exposure to high temperature.

It is still another object to provide an iron base material that exhibits grain-stability at elevated temperatures.

These and other objects will become more apparent when taken in conjunction with the following description and the accompanying figures, wherein:

FIG. 1 is a photomicrograph taken at 50 diameters of an iron-base product made according to the present invention, which product was cold-rolled 50 percent and grain coarsened by heating at 2,400F. for one hour.

P10. 2 is a photomicrograph taken at 100 diameters of a wire produced according to the present invention which wire was exposed to a temperature of 2400F. for 160 hours.

Generally speaking, the present invention includes the mechanical alloying of powder charges containing by weight, about 10 percent to about 40 percent chromium; up to about 10 percent aluminum, e.g., about 1 percent to about 10 percent aluminum; up to about 20 percent cobalt; up to about 10 percent nickel; up to about 5 percent titanium; up to about 2 percent each of rare earth metal, yttrium, zirconium, columbium, hafnium, tantalum, silicon, and/or vanadium; up to about 6 percent each of tungsten and molybdenum; and the balance essentially iron, and further including by volume, up to about 10 percent finely divided dispersoid material consisting of oxides, nitrides, carbides, borides and other refractory materials, which dispersoid material has a melting point of at least about 2750F.; hot consolidating the mechanically alloyed powder to a substantially completely dense body (e.g., about 98 percent theoretical density or more); working the consolidated body at a temperature within the range up to about l600F. to 1700F. to achieve a reduction of about 10 to percent or more therein; and then heating the worked body to an elevated graingrowth temperature to produce coarse grains elongated in the direction or directions of working and to provide improved stress-rupture properties therein.

More preferably, the powder charge and consolidated material produced therefrom contain, by weight about l5 to 40 percent chromium, and even more preferably, about 18 percent to about 26 percent chromium; up to about 5 percent cobalt; up to about 6 percent nickel; about 1 percent to about 7 percent aluminum, e.g., about 3 to 7 percent aluminum; up to about 0.5 percent zirconium; up to about 1 percent titanium; about 0.1 percent to about 10 percent or more preferably, about 0.25 to 5 percent dispersoid in the form of a finely divided, well-distributed refractory dispersoid; such as a refractory oxide, including alumina, lanthana, yttria, ceria, titania, silica, zirconia, hafnia, for example; a metal carbide; and/or a metal nitride, such as zirconium nitride; and the balance essentially iron. Elements such as carbon and manganese are regarded as impurities and may be present in amounts up to about 0.4 percent each. The dispersoid particles preferably have a particle size of about 50A. to 5000A., more preferably about 100A. to 1000A., and have average interparticle spacings of about 500A. to about 2500A, more preferably, about 660A. to about 1800A.

More specifically, in one embodiment of the present invention, the mechanical alloying operation is carried out in a stirred ball mill, e.g., a Szegvari attritor, provided with an attrition medium comprising balls having an average diameter of 0.1 to 0.5 inches and running at an impeller speed of about 50 to 350 RPM. The halls are present in an amount sufficient to provide a ball-topowder ratio, preferably, of about from 4 to 1 to about 50 to i. It is preferred that higher impeller speeds be employed in mechanical alloying with stirred ball mills having relatively small powder chambers and lower impeller speeds be employed with relatively large such chambers; for example, with chambers having respective diameters of about 9 and about 36inches, the respective impeller speeds can be about 300 to 400 RPM and about 70 to 100 RPM. The mechanical alloying operation preferably is carried out for a time sufficient, in the particular milling device employed, to ensure the substantial homogeneity of the final composite particles and to impart substantial saturation hardness to the composite particles. Experience indicates that milling times of about 10 to about hours, e.g., about 15 to about 20 hours, are usually sufficient in a high energy mill such as the attritor.

It is preferred that the mechanical alloying operation be conducted in an inert atmosphere such as argon and, preferably at a flow rate sufficient to prevent substantial infiltration of air into the mill, e.g., about 5 cu. ft. of argon per hr. in a mill having an internat volume of 10 to 15 gallons, so that the uncontrolled pickup of gases such as oxygen and nitrogen in the powders is minimized. It appears that the presence of excessive oxygen, and possibly also nitrogen, in the mill atmosphere during milling can hinder the welding factor which desirably occurs during mechanical alloying, may lead to the production of undesirably fine powders and contribute to inhomogeneity. Preferably, the amount of nitrogen and of oxygen in the powder, other than that present in the dispersoid material, due to atmosphere pickup in milling, does not exceed about 0.4 percent oxygen and 0.2 percent nitrogen. Satisfactory composite powders generally have average particle sizes in the range 10 to 1000 microns, e.g., about 20 to 200 microns.

ln satisfactory mechanically alloyed, i.e., composite, powders produced from powder mixtures containing dispersoid powder, the dispersoid ingredient is present in the powder in a total amount of, by volume, about 0.1 to 10 percent and is well distributed throughout the composite at average interparticle distances from about 500 to 2,500 Angstroms. Once this dispersoid content and distribution has been established in the powder, it is carried forward into the consolidated material. It is found that the characteristic high hardness, or saturation hardness, is developed in the composite powder after relatively short milling periods and this hardness will generally be on the order of 630 Vickers Hardness Number. The composite powder is dense and substantially devoid of internal porosity such that it withstands penetration by a diamond pyramid indenter, Generally, milling is continued substantially beyond the point at which substantial saturation hardness is achieved in the composite powder for the purpose of further improving the homogeneity of the powder with beneficial results in terms of strength and ductility in consolidated powders made therefrom, as well as avoidance of segregated areas in the consolidated material made therefrom.

The powder charges that can be converted to mechanically alloyed powders having the compositional requirements set forth herein, may include iron powder, e. g., sponge iron, reduced mill scale, decarburized carbonyl iron powder, etc., generally having a particle size not exceeding 100 mesh. Chromium may be introduced into the charge as chromium powder, e.g., electrolytic chromium having a particle size not exceeding 100 mesh, or ferrochromium powder containing about to percent chromium and not more than about 0.2 percent carbon, and the balance iron, having a particle size not exceeding mesh. Aluminum may be introduced as an iron-aluminum master alloy powder containing 50 to 80 percent aluminum and the balance iron and other desired ingredients, e.g., iron, chromium, aluminum, etc. Additionally, the chromium and the aluminum, when desired, can be incorporated into the initial powder mixture as an iron-chromiumaluminum master alloy powder. It is preferred that the nitrogen content of the initial'powder charge be sufficiently low to provide mechanically alloyed powder containing less than 0.2 weight per cent nitrogen.

The mechanically alloyed composite powders are thereafter hot consolidated as, for example, by canning (in a can which may be mild steel, stainless steel, nickel, etc., and which is welded shut after filling with powder) and hot extruding the powder, or by other hot compaction steps. Powder extrusion can be carried out at an elevated temperature up to 1600F. or higher, e.g., 2000F. or 2400F., the extrusion ratio preferably being about 5:1 to 50:1 or higher. The consolidated powder products can then be fabricated into various shapes; for example, the consolidated powder products can be hot and/or cold rolled to plate or sheet, or rolled, swaged or drawn to bar, rod or wire. Such fabrication can be carried out at elevated temperatures, e.g., up to about 2000F. or even higher, or at ambient temperature, intermediate anneals preferably being utilized in the latter case (i.e., fabrication at ambient temperature) after reductions of about 50 percent.

The consolidated product is then worked (i.e., drawn, forged, rolled, etc.) at temperatures not exceeding about 1600F. to 1700F. so as to permit the production of coarse, elongated grains on subsequent heat treatment. Heat treatment of the consolidated product without post-consolidation working thereof generally does not result in coarse, elongated grains. The required amount of working of the consolidated product generally decreases with increasing dispersoid content thereof and is preferably about to 12 percent reduction or more; for example, a cold-working reduction of about 16 percent to about percent or more can be employed with a consolidated product having a total dispersoid content of up to about 1 to 2 volume percent.

In general, the amount of working of the consolidated product before the grain-coarsening, or secondary recrystallization, heat treatment and the graincoarsening heat-treatment temperature that are required to achieve elongated, relatively coarse grains are a function of the amount of stored energy in the consolidated product. Usually, higher amounts of such stored energy can be produced by mechanically alloying for longer periods of time and/or consolidating, e.g., by extrusion, the mechanically-alloyed powder at lower temperatures and/or with greater amounts of working or deformation of the powder. It is generally desired that the amount of working before the graincoarsening heat treatment be sufficient to induce strains, i.e., provide stored energy, throughout the consolidated product so that coarse, elongated grains can subsequently be generated substantially completely throughout the product.

Following such working, the product is subjected to a grain-coarsening heat treatment at an elevated temperature which may be about 2,200F. up to a temperature below the incipient melting point of the alloy. In some cases, for example, when the mechanical alloying operation is conducted for longer times or when extrusion conditions including extrusion strain rate, are

more severe or when greater amounts of working are accomplished, or when lower dispersoid contents, e.g,

less than about 1 percent by volume, are present in the consolidated alloy, the grain-coarsening heat treatment can be conducted at significantly lower temperatures, e.g., temperatures as low as 1600F. In terms of stressrupture properties, it appears that no significant difference results whether grain coarsening occurs at a relatively low temperature or at a higher temperature. Grain coarsening is itself the significant parameter and the phenomenon does not occur unless work is imparted to the material after hot consolidation. It is generally found that higher temperatures are required where the product includes about 0.5 percent or more, by weight, zirconium, or where the powder is mechanically alloyed for relatively short periods, e.g., about 15 hours. Such heating results in grain growth, wherein the grains of the product grow to a definite desired size that is not substantially exceeded even after subsequent sustained exposure to temperatures approaching the melting point of the alloy, e.g., about 2,350F. to 2,400F. for 100 hours or more, which grains are elongated in the direction or directions of working and generally have dimensions in the range of about 10 to l00-microns wide and about 50 to 2000 microns long, when viewed two-dimensionally. Such larger grains provide significant improvement in high temperature tensile and stress-rupture strengths. Products made according to the invention also exhibit elevated temperature grain stability, room temperature workability, comparatively high room-temperature tensile strength, and reduced tendency for embrittlement at ambient temperatures after extended exposure to elevated temperature.

As an alternative to the addition of dispersoid particles directly to the initial powder charge, such dispersoid particles can be produced by adding precursor material to the initial powder charge and thereafter converting such precursor material to the appropriate dispersoid composition. For example, there can be added to the initial powder charge particles of zirconium metal and/or misch metal, after which the zirconium and/or misch metal is converted to the oxide form (i.e., zirconia, lanthana, ceria, etc.). Such conversion to the dispersoid composition can be achieved, for example, by introducing controlled amounts of oxygen into the charge before or during the mechanical alloying operation. Thus, a readily reducible metal oxide such as iron oxide, nickel oxide, etc., having a negative free energy of formation substantially below kilocalories per gram atom of oxygen at 25C. can be added to the powder charge, or oxygen gas can be included in a mixture with argon during milling, so as to form a fine dispersoid oxide by diffusion and internal oxidation when the resulting powder is hot consolidated. Where the desired dispersoid particles are nitrides, (e.g. ZrN), controlled amounts of nitrogen can be introduced into the mill in the form of nitrogen gas mixed with argon, for example. While oxide and nitride compounds have been mentioned as dispersoid particle compositions, other types of dispersoid materials can also be used in the present invention, e.g., up to about 10 percent of one or more hard phases, such as carbides, borides, and the like. Refractorycompounds which may be included in the powder mix or produced in situ include oxides, carbides, nitrides, borides of such refractory metals as thorium, zirconium,,hafnium, titanium, and even such refractory oxides as those of silicon, aluminum, yt-

trium, cerium, uranium, magnesium, calcium, beryllium and the like. In general, the refractory dispersoid material has a preferred melting point of at least about 2750F. The refractory oxides generally include the oxides of those metals whose negative free energy of formation of the oxide per gram mole of oxygen at about 1000C. is at "least about 150 kilocalories. The refractory nitrides include those metal nitrides having a negative free energy of formation of at least about 25 kilocalories per gram mole of nitrogen at 1000C. and the refractory carbides include metal carbides having a negative free energy of formation of at least about l kilocalories per gram atom of carbon at 1000C.

EXAMPLE 1 8.5 kilograms of a powder mixture comprising, by weight, 28.7 percent minus 100 mesh ferrochromium powder, 1 percent cobalt powder, having an average particle size of 5 microns, 61 percent minus 100 mesh iron powder, 6 percent minus 100 mesh ferroaluminum including 65 percent aluminum, 2.5 percent 100 mesh ferroaluminum including 65 percent aluminum and 10 percent cerium-free misch metal, 0.3 percent of ferrocolumbium including 67 percent columbium and 0.5 percent of ferrozirconium including 10 percent zirconium, was mechanically alloyed for a period of 18 hours in a IO-gallon capacity Szegvari attritor. The mechanical alloying was carried out with 380 lbs. of 5/ 1 6- inch diameter steel balls, providing a ball-to-powder ratio of 20 to 1, at an impeller speed of 180 RPM and in an argon atmosphere provided by an argon stream flowing at 5 cubic feet per hour. A portion of the mechanically alloyed powder was canned and extruded at 1950E from 3%. inches to a 11-inch diameter bar which had the composition, by weight, 5.7 percent aluminum, 21.5 percent chromium, 0.9 percent cobalt, 0.16 percent manganese, 0.15 percent nickel, 0.016 percent zirconium, 0.035 percent carbon, 0.24 percent oxygen, niobium not determined), 0.12 percent nitrogen, and the balance essentially iron, the total dispersoid content, including rare earth oxides, of the bar being about 1 percent. A portion of the extruded bar was subsequently bar rolled at room temperature to a strain of 40 percent reduction in area, and annealed for one hour at 2400F. The bar exhibited grain growth as evidenced by grains having average dimensions of about 100 microns in width and about 1000 microns in length.

Another portion of the same extruded bar was cold bar rolled by 50 percent reduction in thickness and subjected to a grain-coarsening heat treatment at 2,400F. for 2 hours, the resulting grains (FIG. I) having an average size of about 2000 microns long by about 100 microns wide. The thus-treated bar survived a step-loaded stress-rupture test at 1900F. comprising 162.7 hours at 5,000 psi, 47.9 hours at 6000 psi, 24

hours at 7000 psi, and 24 hours at 8000 psi, with the final duration being 33.4 hours at 9000 psi. The bar broke with 2.5 percent elongation and 7 percent reduction in area.

EXAMPLE 11 I An extrusion having the same composition as that described in Example I was produced with a powder mixture and under the processing conditions similar to those described in Example I, except that the mechanical alloying time in this instance was 12 hours. The extrusion, which was fine grained, was turned to a 0.4- inch diameter and drawn at room temperature to a 0.277-inch diameter rod which was then annealed at 2000F. for one hour and further drawn to about 0.1- inch diameter. i.e., a severe reduction of about percent, without intermediate anneals. The wire was annealed at 2400F. for various times of /2 to hours, the wire grains, after each of the annealing times being elongated in the working directions and being, on the average, about 200 microns long and about 20 microns wide, as illustrated in FIG. 2, which is the grain structure of the 160 hour annealed wire. The relative uniformity of grain size of the wires annealed at the various temperatures indicates the grain stability that is present therein at elevated temperatures. For comparison, a commercially available %-inch diameter wire of the composition by weight, 5.55 percent aluminum, 21.0 percent chromium, 0.85 percent cobalt. 0.1 percent manganese, 0.1 percent silicon, 0.25 percent titanium, 0.19 percent nickel, 0.19 percent rare earth metal, balance iron, was heated at 2400F. for hours. The commercial wire, which had an average initial grain size of about 40 microns, exhibited very extensive, uncontrolled grain growth as a result of the high temperature heating, the grown grains of the commercial wire being essentially equiaxed and having an average size of 1200 microns.

To determine the effects of exposure to high temperature or their room temperature properties, another piece of the above commercial wire and a second dispersion-strengthened wire, which was similar in composition to that above and was produced in the manner described above except that it was grain coarsened by heating for /2 hour at 2400F., were annealed at 2400F. for various times and then tested at room temperature. The various exposure times and the test re sults are indicated at Table 1, from which it can be seen that the commercial wire is embrittled after only a short exposure, (i.e., less than 2.5 hours) at 2400F., but that the grain coarsened wire is strong and ductile at room temperature even after 120 hours at 2400F. The poor ductility of the dispersion-strengthened wire in the as-drawn condition can be attributed to the severe cold working that it underwent in the drawing operation.

TABLE 1 Room Temperature Properties Another commercial 41 inch-diameter wire bar and a third grain-coarsened 0.10 inch-diameter dispersion strengthened wire, which had been produced in the above manner and grain coarsened by heating at 2400F. for 7% hour, were tested at 1900F. for, respectively, static mechanical properties, i.e., yield strength (Y.S.),' ultimate tensile strength (U.T.S.), elongation (EL) and reduction in area (R.A.) and stress-rupture strength, the results being set out in Table 11.

TABLE II [900F. PROPERTIES Commercial Wire 0.2% Y.S.. U.T.S., El., R.A.,

(ksi) (ksi) Dispersion Strengthened Wire Stress Life (ksi) (hrs! EXAMPLE III A portion of the mechanically alloyed powder described in Example I was canned and hot compacted in a closed extrusion container at 2100F. to form a 3 /2 inch diameter compact having fine grain size. The compact was heated to 2100F. and rolled from 3 /2 inch diameter round to a 3-inch square and then to a 2 inch thick rectangle which was cross-rolled to l-inch thick plate. The plate was reheated to 2100F. and rolled to 0.25-inch plate. The plate was annealed at 1800F. for 2 hours, decanned by pickling and then cold-rolled to 0.190 inches, after which the plate was annealed at 2200F. for 2 hours and then cold-rolled to 0.055 inch thick sheet and annealed at 2400F. for /2 hour to achieve grain coarsening. No difficulty was encountered in either hot or cold rolling. The sheet exhibits the same type of grain structure as that described in Example II, i.e., elongated grains of relatively large size (about 200 microns long and 20 microns wide) produced by grain growth.

EXAMPLE IV Various powder lots having compositions adjusted to provide product compositions shown in Table III were mechanically alloyed in a -gallon capacity Szegvari attritor at an impeller speed of 180 RPM and under a dynamic argon atmosphere flowing at 5 cubic feet per hour for the mechanical alloying times given in Table III.

Each mechanically alloyed powder was canned in a 3 /2 inch diameter mild steel can and consolidated without evacuation of the can by extruding at 2000F. to %-inch diameter bars, which were then turned to 0.664-inch diameter. When portions of the bars were heated at 2400F. for /2 hour in an attempt to achieve grain coarsening therein, no grain coarsening resulted. Bars produced from Powder Nos. 1,2,3, 6 and 7 were then individually rolled at room temperature to various reductions of 16 to 41 percent. A portion of each bar was removed after each reduction step, each of these portions then being heated at 2400F. for 16 hour and inspected for grain coarsening, the results being given in Table IV, where the consolidated products are assigned the same numbers as their corresponding powclers.

The dispersoid particles generally ranged in size from about 150A. to about 500A., with average interparticle spacings of about 1 100A. for Bar No. 1, about 800A. for Bar Nos. 2,4 and 5, and about 650A. for Bar Nos. 3,6 and 7, these values occurring in both the extrusions and in the grain-coarsened products.

TABLE IV Grain Coarsening (Percent) COLD REDUCTION (2) Each bar annealed at 2400F. for V: hour after cold rolling.

From Table IV, the bars that were tested, (i.e., Nos. 1 to 3,6 and 7) did not grain coarsen, i.e., secondary recrystallize, under the heating conditions employed until some cold deformation was produced therein. While Bar No. 2 did not grain coarsen until the cold deformation thereof had reached 25 percent, Bar Nos. 1,6 and 7 were fully grain coarsened and Bar No. 3 was percent grain coarsened after the 16 percent reduction and heat treatment. Each one of these bars was fully grain coarsened, i.e., comprised substantially completely of coarse, elongated grains, after cold reductions of 25 percent or more and heat treatments at 2,400F. for /2 hour.

EXAMPLE V Various portions of each one of the extrusions, Nos. 1 through 7, described in Example IV were cold-rolled to achieve a 25 percent reduction therein and then TAKE III 7 7- Element Weight Percent Total Rare Earth Oxide Powder Y "V No.(l) C Ni Cr A1 Co 0 N Zr 3 mechanically alloyed for 15. 24. and 36 hours. respectively.

heated for /2 hour at various temperatures from 1600F. to 2400F., after which the thus-treated bars were metallographically examined for the presence of coarse, elongated grains, the results being given in Table V.

(3) Each bar cold rolled 25% reduction before anneal.

From Table V, all of the bars displayed a relatively coarse, elongated grain after cold rolling 25 percent reduction and heating for /2 hour at a temperature of 2400F. Comparing Bars No. 2 and 3 with Bar No. 1, it appears that the grain coarsening temperature under these conditions, increases with higher dispersoid contents (Table lll). Comparing Bars No. 4 and 5, it appears that the grain coarsening temperature under these conditions also increases with higher zirconium contents (see Table Ill), the zirconium being thought to form additional dispersoid material, such as an oxide, carbide or nitride. Comparison of Bars No. 3 and 6 leads to the conclusion that, under these conditions of cold work and heat treatment, the temperature needed for total grain coarsening decreases with longer mechanical alloying times.

EXAMPLE VI Various products made from the mechanically alloyed powders described in Example IV were tested for TAELE V] N V that specimens (Bars No. l and 4) corresponding to Bars No. l and 4 of Table Vl grain coarsen at temperatures below l9UOF.. so that these Bars No. l and 4 in the cold-worked condition grain coarsened on heating up to the l900F. test temperature and the subsequent 2400F. anneal for /2 hour had no apparent beneficial effect on their strength properties.

Although the present invention has been described in conjunction with preferred embodiments, it is to be understood that modifications and variations may be resorted to without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention, as those skilled in the art will readily understand. Such modifications and variations are considered to be within the purview and scope of the invention and appended claims.

We claim:

1. A method of producing a powder metallurgy product comprising:

a. hot consolidating a mechanically alloyed powder produced by mechanically alloying a powder mixture consisting essentially of, by weight, at least one element from the group consisting of about 10 percent to about percent chromium and about 1 percent to about 10 percent aluminum, up to about 10 percent nickel, up to about 20 percent cobalt, up to about 2 percent each of rare earth metal. yttrium, zirconium, columbium, hafnium, tantalum, silicon, and/or vanadium, up to about 6 percent each of tungsten and molybdenum, and the balance iron, further comprising up to about It) volume percent dispersoid material having a melting point of at least 2750F., and working the consolidated product at a temperature not higher than the temperature range of about 1600F. to about 1700F. to achieve therein a reduction of at least about 10 percent, such that the resulting worked material will undergo grain coarsening when subjected to an elevated grain coarsening temperature.

2. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said reduction is at least about 15 percent.

3. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said reduction is at least about 25 percent.

l900F. Stress Rupture (4) Estimated Estimated Estimated Stress for Stress for Cold Worked 25% and Stress for As Extruded [00 Hour Cold Worked 25% 100 Hour Annealed tie-2400311 I00 Hour Bar No. Stress Life Elong. Life (ksi) Stress Life Elong. Life (ksi) Stress Life Elong. Life (ksi) 1 5 0.4 6.4 2.4 5 3.1 2.4 3.5 7 0.1 8.8 3.5 2 5 6.2 4.0 3.7 5 68.4 4.0 4.8 7 27.5 0.0 6.2 3 5 0.l 33.6 2.5 5 13.3 0 8 4.t 7 17.7 1.2 5.8 4 5 0.l 39.2 2.5 5 350.0 5.6 7 101.9 2.4 7.0 5 4 1.2 8.8 2.6 5 54.] 1.6 4.7 7 5.1 4.1 5.2 6 4 1.1 9.6 2.6 5 2.0 4.0 3.4 6 1.0 1.6 3.8 7 4 0.5 16.0 2.4 5 2.3 2.4 3.4 7 8.6 3.2 5.4

(4) All stresses in k.s.i.: all lives in hours; all clongations in Z 4. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said mechanical alloying is conducted in an inert atmosphere.

5. The method defined in claim 4, wherein said atmosphere consists essentially of argon. 

2. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said reduction is at least about 15 percent.
 3. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said reduction is at least about 25 percent.
 4. The method defined in claim 1, wherein said mechanical alloying is conducted in an inert atmosphere.
 5. The method defined in claim 4, wherein said atmosphere consists essentially of argon. 